Best Undercounter Ice Makers
On this page
The best undercounter ice maker is the one that makes the ice you actually want and that your cabinet run can drain. Decide between clear, nugget, and crescent ice first, then check where the drain is, because that decides whether you need a pump model. The same two checks apply to any built-in ice maker that sits under a counter.
| Line | What the maker lists | Ice type | Daily output and bin, per the maker |
|---|---|---|---|
| True Residential 15" Clear Ice Machine | drain pump and water filter on all models, UL approved for outdoor use | clear | up to 85 lb a day (rated 75 lb), 28 lb bin |
| Sub-Zero Designer Undercounter Indoor/Outdoor Ice Maker (DEU1550) | indoor and outdoor options, pump and non-pump models | not stated on the maker page | up to 65 lb a day, stores up to 25 lb |
| U-Line 15" 1 Class Clear Ice Machine (HCP115) | stainless, black, white, or panel-ready door | clear | up to 55 lb a day, 25 lb bin |
| Scotsman Brilliance Cuber (SRC065) | 15" cabinet width, indoor and outdoor rated, built-in drain pump available | clear "gourmet" cube | up to 65 lb in 24 hours, 26 lb bin |
| Scotsman Brilliance Nugget (SRN110) | 15" cabinet width, approved for indoor or outdoor use, built-in drain pump available | nugget | ask us for the current spec sheet; 26 lb bin |
| Perlick | 15" clear and cubelet ice makers, ADA-height versions, panel-ready or stainless doors | clear or cubelet | ask us for the current spec sheet |
| Marvel | 15" clear ice machines with gravity drain or pump, crescent ice makers, nugget | all three | ask us for the current spec sheet |
Clear, nugget, or crescent
The ice type decides which kind of machine you need.
Crescent ice comes from what U-Line calls an ice maker. U-Line explains that an ice maker freezes water into cubes, drops them into a bucket, keeps the ice frozen, and doesn't make more until it senses the bucket is low. Marvel says its crescent models are the option that doesn't require a drain. U-Line describes crescent ice as "ideal for everyday refreshments."
Clear ice comes from an ice machine. U-Line says its clear ice machine freezes water in layers, discards impurities, and drops the finished cube into a bin that works as a cooler rather than a freezer, which keeps the cubes clear. U-Line also says ice machines require a drain. Scotsman describes its gourmet cubers as producing crystal-clear, odorless cubes that melt slower, and says its machines are designed, engineered, and assembled in South Carolina.
Nugget ice is soft, chewable ice. U-Line says its nugget machines freeze water, shave it with an auger, and compact the shavings into nuggets in a bin that also works as a cooler. Scotsman says nugget ice is made from compacted flakes, which makes it softer than its cubes.
If you mainly want ice for cocktails and spirits, start with clear. If you want ice for soft drinks and smoothies, look at nugget. If a drain is impossible where the unit goes, crescent is the format the makers list without one.
Daily output and bin storage
Two numbers matter, and they measure different things. Daily output is how much ice the machine can make in 24 hours. Bin storage is how much it holds at once.
Read the rating conditions too. True Residential lists its clear ice machine at up to 85 pounds a day at 70°F air and 50°F water, and a rated 75 pounds a day at 90°F air and 70°F water, with a 28-pound bin. A hot garage bar or an outdoor island in a Sacramento summer runs closer to the second set of conditions, so compare machines at the same conditions where the makers publish them.
For a party, the bin is what you draw from first. Sub-Zero says its Designer Undercounter Ice Maker stores up to 25 pounds and can make up to 65 pounds a day. Scotsman lists a 26-pound bin on both Brilliance models.
Drain pump or gravity drain
Find the drain before you choose the ice maker. Where the drain sits against the machine's drain connection decides between a gravity model and a pump model, and each maker sets its own limits:
- Gravity drain needs the drain low. Sub-Zero's installation guide for its current Designer Series undercounter ice maker says that on gravity drain models, the drain connection and all excess drain tubing can't sit more than 7 inches above the bottom of the leveling legs, and it asks for the drain tubing to be cut as short as possible.
- Pump drain models lift the water to the drain. Sub-Zero offers the Designer ice maker in pump and non-pump models, and its guide says to connect a pump model's drain tube following local code.
Some makers build the pump in. True Residential says a drain pump is standard on all its clear ice machines, and its install guide asks for a check valve (supplied by True), drain hose no smaller than 1/4 inch inside diameter, a discharge line that ends at an open site drain, and an added external pump if the vertical rise is more than 84 inches. Scotsman lists a built-in drain pump as available on both Brilliance models, and Marvel lists its 15-inch clear machine with a gravity drain or with a pump.
Have a licensed plumber confirm the drain, the water line, and any air gap your local building department requires before the cabinets are set.
Outdoor-rated ice makers
An outdoor ice maker needs the maker's outdoor rating for that exact model. True Residential says all its undercounter ice machines are rated for outdoor use, that the unit must be covered or otherwise protected from direct rain, and that it should be built into an undercounter area of stone, brick, or wood. True also says to winterize the machine before it sees freezing temperatures and lists an allowable air temperature of 40°F to 100°F. U-Line lists outdoor clear and outdoor nugget models, and Scotsman lists both Brilliance models for indoor and outdoor use. For the island itself, see what an outdoor rating asks of the island.
Water, power, and the cabinet
True Residential's install guide lists a water pressure range of 20 to 80 psig and a 115-volt, 60-hertz, 15-amp circuit for its machine, and says it has a built-in water filter with change reminders. Every model has its own requirements, so plan the outlet with a licensed electrician from the maker's guide for the model you choose.
Most of these units are 15 inches wide, which lets them sit next to a 24-inch undercounter refrigerator or a dishwasher in a bar run. Perlick and U-Line both list ADA-height versions, and Sub-Zero, U-Line, and Perlick list panel-ready doors. If you're planning the whole run, compare undercounter refrigerators for the same bar run and browse built-in refrigeration and ice.
For what happens after you order, see delivery and installation for an undercounter ice machine.
Energy
True Residential lists its clear ice machine as "Energy Star Listed." Scotsman says its Brilliance Nugget uses 40% less energy and more than 50% less water than its gourmet cube machines. If energy matters to you, ask for the ENERGY STAR status of the exact model.
Questions to ask in the showroom
- Clear, nugget, or crescent: which ice do we actually use most?
- Where is the nearest drain, and is it above or below the unit's drain connection?
- Does this model come with a pump built in, or do I order a pump version?
- What daily output does the maker list, and at what air and water temperatures?
- Is this exact model outdoor-rated, and what does the maker say about rain and winterizing?
- Is there a panel-ready or ADA-height version for my cabinet run?
Next steps in the Sacramento area
Start with ice maker planning with our Sacramento-area team, then bring your cabinet drawings and a photo of the plumbing under the sink or bar to the Roseville showroom. We'll pull the current spec sheets and install guides with you so the drain and the cabinet opening are settled before the cabinets are ordered.
Updated